1939 / Best Actor / Best Director / Best Picture / Best Supporting Actor

Film #103: Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)

By helming seven Best Picture nominees, it’s fair to say that Frank Capra was one of the Oscars’ early success stories. I personally feel that I’ve left one of his strongest nominated pictures till last; Mr Smith Goes to Washington.

The film features James Stewart’s Boy Scout Leader Jefferson Smith who becomes the surprise choice to take over from the previous senator in his state. Originally the film had been intended as a follow up to Capra’s Mr Deeds Goes to Town with Gary Cooper reviving the Deeds role and entering the senate. However when it was revealed Cooper wasn’t available Capra decided it would be a perfect vehicle for Stewart and Jean Arthur who had previously played the central couple in You Can’t Take It With You. When Smith gets to Washington he is awe-inspired by the architecture and the history that the place has but is ridiculed by the press for being a simpleton. Smith is taken under the wing of Senator Paine, his father’s oldest and best friend as well as charming over Arthur’s Saunders, Paine’s Chief-of-Staff. Smith proposes a new legislation to approve a government loan to allow for some land to be purchased in his state for a national Boy’s Camp, and the loan will be paid back by donations from the scouts. Paine is leaned on by the manipulative political adviser Jim Taylor to quash Smith because the land is already part of a dam-building scheme constructed by Taylor. Paine decides to make out that Smith owns the land and is defrauding the scouts but by this stage Saunders is on Smith’s side and uncovers Taylor’s corruption. The film’s most famous scene is where Smith decides to embark on a filibuster, holding the floor and speaking for as long as possible without sitting down, when all the senators leave the room. Taylor and Paine try and break his spirit by rigging the press in Taylor’s state and making out that no-one is supporting him but he finds solace in a smile from the senate’s president. At the end of the film Smith collapses from exhaustion and Paine tries to commit suicide when he is stopped he confesses everything and Smith’s reputation is redeemed.

Just like with Stewart and Capra’s most famous collaboration, It’s a Wonderful Life, Mr Smith Goes to Washington is remembered for its final scenes. However before that there is a lot that no-one ever thinks about including the scene where Smith tries to punch a lot of journalists after they insult him and Smith’s romance with Paine’s daughter which is used as a distraction for Smith’s plans. However there is a lot to like here, Capra’s themes of the underdog triumphing is possibly at its most blatant here with the innocent and ultimately good Smith gets one over on the cowardly Paine and the tyrannical Taylor. Jean Arthur again proves that she is the most consistent of Capra’s female leads, with Saunders she portrays a woman trying to survive in a masculine world and has almost lost all her femininity to do so. In fact there is no romantic end to her relationship with Smith however her greatest moment is when someone calls her Clarissa, her first name, which makes her feel somewhat human. Stewart himself is able to play a real, likeable if innocent character with ease. Elsewhere, there are some fine supporting performances from Claude Rains as the multi-layered Paine and Edward Arnold as the just plain evil Taylor. Of the cast Rains, Stewart and Harry Carey; who played the President of the Senate, were all nominated for Oscar however none were ultimately successful. Mr Smith Goes to Washington’s only Oscar win was in the screenplay but I the film may have garnered more awards had it not been up against eventual Best Picture winner Gone With the Wind. Overall, I would say that the uplifting and incredibly well-performed Mr. Smith Goes to Washington is a more than fitting way to end Capra’s time on this blog.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s